imac
07-04-2003, 21:10
Customer: "Hi, I can't seem to connect you guys are you having a problem?"
Tech Support: "Well sir, what dialup software are you using?"
Customer: "The one you provided."
Tech Support: "And what version is it?"
Customer: (says the version number)
Tech Support: "Oh, that's the problem you need the latest version."
Customer: "Ok, how do I get it?"
Tech Support: "Well, just transfer the file via FTP."
Customer: "Well that would be nice, but I can't connect to the Internet."
Tech Support: (sounding exasperated) "I told you just to FTP the file sir."
I hung up.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I use a cable modem ISP, one of North America's largest ISPs. During one of their interminable outages,
I called to demand what the problem was.
Tech Support: "Is your computer on? Is the modem plugged in?"
Me: "Yes, it's on and working fine. The modem's plugged in, but it isn't getting anything from your end."
Tech Support: "Ok, can you click on the 'Start' button and type 'WINIPCFG'--"
Me: "Yes, I know. My IP is listed as 169.XXX.XXX.XXX."
This IP was the one Windows 98 usually gives when it's supposed to have one assigned to it but doesn't get one.
Tech Support: "Well, sir, that's the problem."
Me: "Yes, I know. I'm getting no IP. I'm not in the network."
Tech Support: "No, sir, the problem is that you're using a Mac."
Er....
Me: "I'm sorry?"
Tech Support: "Sir, your IP is a Mac IP. You're not using a PC."
Me: "Uhhh, I am using a PC. It's a Dell with an Intel PII-450 CPU. I'm running Windows 98."
Tech Support: "No, sir. Your IP indicates that your computer is a Mac. IPs that start with those numbers
are used by Macs."
Me: "You know, I don't think it works that way. I'm pretty certain IPs are assigned based on where the
computer is in a domain and a subdomain and such. I know all your IPs assigned in this area start
with XXX. And I'm quite certain my computer is a PC."
Tech Support: "I don't think we use 'domain' here."
Me: "Can I speak to a supervisor, please?"
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This incident happened to me in India. This was in 1992-3 when Windows 3.1 was becoming popular.
My machine had a CGA card and monitor, which I exchanged for a VGA card and monitor.
The machine booted up -- there were no warning beeps -- but nothing was appearing on the screen.
So I called up tech support.
Customer: "The computer boots up without any warning beeps, but nothing shows up on the screen."
Tech Support: "Is the monitor connected."
Customer: "Yes, but there is no display."
Tech Support: "Did you install the drivers for the VGA card?"
Customer: "How can I install them before I'm in DOS?"
Tech Support: "You have to install the drivers first before you can get a display."
Customer: "You don't need VGA drivers to boot to DOS like you do for Windows. I should be able to boot to DOS."
Tech Support: "Well, insert the floppy you received with your card. Go to the A:\Utilities directory. Type 'readme.com'."
Customer: "I cannot see anything. How do you expect me to read a file on the screen?"
Tech Support: "Read the file, and it will explain everything."
I hung up. The problem was that the monitor was broken. I took it to the shop and proved it, and they gave me
a replacement.
------------------------------------------------
My school district decided to require us school psychologists to do all our reports on laptops and print from a
single printer. After a few months the laptop they provided me ceased to work with the printer. I spoke with the
IT Manager.
IT Manager: "I don't know if the problem is a hardware problem or a software problem."
Me: "Ok."
IT Manager: "So I can't solve the problem now."
Me: "When can you solve it?"
IT Manager: "I told you: I don't know if it is a hardware problem or a software problem. I can't fix it until I know."
Me: "Ok. I need to print my reports. When will I be able to?"
IT Manager: (angrily) "Look, if it's a hardware problem I can't fix it! I don't know if it is a hardware or a software problem."
I made several more attempts to communicate with the IT manager about this problem over the next few weeks,
only to find myself in the same conversation. Finally, I sent a memo to my boss, explaining that I was having
difficulty getting tech support and could not print out my reports. My boss wrote back:
Boss: "Please do not harass the IT Manager anymore. He has already explained to you that he doesn't know
whether it is a software problem or a hardware problem."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About a year ago, my mother was having problems with her brand new computer. She hadn't had it for a month
before the video card died. She called the customer service line and spoke with a technical support representative,
who diagnosed the problem and promised that they would send a new card to her.
She received the new card and called the 800 number again, this time asking what to do with the card.
The guy that was helping her said, "Do you see the screws on the back of the computer? Well, take them all out
and take off the case. You will see a card that looks like the one you just received. Replace it with the card you
have and put the case back on." And then he hung up.
So here is my mother, staring at the back of her computer, seeing an array of screws, and wondering which ones
she should take out. She followed his directions to the letter and unscrewed all of the screws on the back of her
computer, not just the ones around the casing edge. All of her computer components hit the bottom of the case
with a bang.
When the dust settled and she realized what she had done, she called back, in hysterics. Thankfully, she got a
nice woman who understood and agreed that it was the tech support guy's fault for not staying with her on the
phone. She agreed to ship her a new computer at no charge.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
When I was in college, I needed to connect to the school's network from my own computer in my dorm room.
I knew there was a dial-up number that would allow me to log in and run limited commands. All I needed to know
was the number. So I called the help desk.
Me: "I'm trying to access the University's network from my computer in my dorm room. Can you help me?"
Help Desk: "Which lab are you in?"
Me: "I'm not in a lab. I'm in my room."
Help Desk: "Then you're not on the network."
Me: "But I want to connect over the phone line. What number do I need to dial?"
Help Desk: "You need to call [phone number of help desk]."
Me: "No, that's your phone number. I need a dial-up number for the computer."
Help Desk: "I don't understand. What are you trying to do?"
Me: "I want to connect my computer to the school's network through the dial-up."
Help Desk: "Why don't you use a computer in the lab?"
Me: "That would defeat the purpose of having a computer in my room."
Help Desk: "Well, your computer is not connected to the school network."
Me: "I know! I want to use my modem to connect."
Help Desk: "What's a modem?"
Me: "Never mind."
Tech Support: "Well sir, what dialup software are you using?"
Customer: "The one you provided."
Tech Support: "And what version is it?"
Customer: (says the version number)
Tech Support: "Oh, that's the problem you need the latest version."
Customer: "Ok, how do I get it?"
Tech Support: "Well, just transfer the file via FTP."
Customer: "Well that would be nice, but I can't connect to the Internet."
Tech Support: (sounding exasperated) "I told you just to FTP the file sir."
I hung up.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I use a cable modem ISP, one of North America's largest ISPs. During one of their interminable outages,
I called to demand what the problem was.
Tech Support: "Is your computer on? Is the modem plugged in?"
Me: "Yes, it's on and working fine. The modem's plugged in, but it isn't getting anything from your end."
Tech Support: "Ok, can you click on the 'Start' button and type 'WINIPCFG'--"
Me: "Yes, I know. My IP is listed as 169.XXX.XXX.XXX."
This IP was the one Windows 98 usually gives when it's supposed to have one assigned to it but doesn't get one.
Tech Support: "Well, sir, that's the problem."
Me: "Yes, I know. I'm getting no IP. I'm not in the network."
Tech Support: "No, sir, the problem is that you're using a Mac."
Er....
Me: "I'm sorry?"
Tech Support: "Sir, your IP is a Mac IP. You're not using a PC."
Me: "Uhhh, I am using a PC. It's a Dell with an Intel PII-450 CPU. I'm running Windows 98."
Tech Support: "No, sir. Your IP indicates that your computer is a Mac. IPs that start with those numbers
are used by Macs."
Me: "You know, I don't think it works that way. I'm pretty certain IPs are assigned based on where the
computer is in a domain and a subdomain and such. I know all your IPs assigned in this area start
with XXX. And I'm quite certain my computer is a PC."
Tech Support: "I don't think we use 'domain' here."
Me: "Can I speak to a supervisor, please?"
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This incident happened to me in India. This was in 1992-3 when Windows 3.1 was becoming popular.
My machine had a CGA card and monitor, which I exchanged for a VGA card and monitor.
The machine booted up -- there were no warning beeps -- but nothing was appearing on the screen.
So I called up tech support.
Customer: "The computer boots up without any warning beeps, but nothing shows up on the screen."
Tech Support: "Is the monitor connected."
Customer: "Yes, but there is no display."
Tech Support: "Did you install the drivers for the VGA card?"
Customer: "How can I install them before I'm in DOS?"
Tech Support: "You have to install the drivers first before you can get a display."
Customer: "You don't need VGA drivers to boot to DOS like you do for Windows. I should be able to boot to DOS."
Tech Support: "Well, insert the floppy you received with your card. Go to the A:\Utilities directory. Type 'readme.com'."
Customer: "I cannot see anything. How do you expect me to read a file on the screen?"
Tech Support: "Read the file, and it will explain everything."
I hung up. The problem was that the monitor was broken. I took it to the shop and proved it, and they gave me
a replacement.
------------------------------------------------
My school district decided to require us school psychologists to do all our reports on laptops and print from a
single printer. After a few months the laptop they provided me ceased to work with the printer. I spoke with the
IT Manager.
IT Manager: "I don't know if the problem is a hardware problem or a software problem."
Me: "Ok."
IT Manager: "So I can't solve the problem now."
Me: "When can you solve it?"
IT Manager: "I told you: I don't know if it is a hardware problem or a software problem. I can't fix it until I know."
Me: "Ok. I need to print my reports. When will I be able to?"
IT Manager: (angrily) "Look, if it's a hardware problem I can't fix it! I don't know if it is a hardware or a software problem."
I made several more attempts to communicate with the IT manager about this problem over the next few weeks,
only to find myself in the same conversation. Finally, I sent a memo to my boss, explaining that I was having
difficulty getting tech support and could not print out my reports. My boss wrote back:
Boss: "Please do not harass the IT Manager anymore. He has already explained to you that he doesn't know
whether it is a software problem or a hardware problem."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About a year ago, my mother was having problems with her brand new computer. She hadn't had it for a month
before the video card died. She called the customer service line and spoke with a technical support representative,
who diagnosed the problem and promised that they would send a new card to her.
She received the new card and called the 800 number again, this time asking what to do with the card.
The guy that was helping her said, "Do you see the screws on the back of the computer? Well, take them all out
and take off the case. You will see a card that looks like the one you just received. Replace it with the card you
have and put the case back on." And then he hung up.
So here is my mother, staring at the back of her computer, seeing an array of screws, and wondering which ones
she should take out. She followed his directions to the letter and unscrewed all of the screws on the back of her
computer, not just the ones around the casing edge. All of her computer components hit the bottom of the case
with a bang.
When the dust settled and she realized what she had done, she called back, in hysterics. Thankfully, she got a
nice woman who understood and agreed that it was the tech support guy's fault for not staying with her on the
phone. She agreed to ship her a new computer at no charge.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
When I was in college, I needed to connect to the school's network from my own computer in my dorm room.
I knew there was a dial-up number that would allow me to log in and run limited commands. All I needed to know
was the number. So I called the help desk.
Me: "I'm trying to access the University's network from my computer in my dorm room. Can you help me?"
Help Desk: "Which lab are you in?"
Me: "I'm not in a lab. I'm in my room."
Help Desk: "Then you're not on the network."
Me: "But I want to connect over the phone line. What number do I need to dial?"
Help Desk: "You need to call [phone number of help desk]."
Me: "No, that's your phone number. I need a dial-up number for the computer."
Help Desk: "I don't understand. What are you trying to do?"
Me: "I want to connect my computer to the school's network through the dial-up."
Help Desk: "Why don't you use a computer in the lab?"
Me: "That would defeat the purpose of having a computer in my room."
Help Desk: "Well, your computer is not connected to the school network."
Me: "I know! I want to use my modem to connect."
Help Desk: "What's a modem?"
Me: "Never mind."